Scleral Lenses Vs. Traditional Contact Lenses: Key Differences Explained

By Author: Tatum eyecare
Total Articles: 107
Comment this article

When it comes to correcting vision, contact lenses offer a convenient alternative to glasses. However, not all contact lenses are created equal. While traditional soft contact lenses are the most common option, scleral lenses have emerged as a specialized solution for individuals with complex vision problems and eye conditions.

If you're considering contact lenses and wondering which type is right for you, understanding the differences between scleral lenses and traditional contact lenses can help you make an informed decision.

What Are Traditional Contact Lenses?

Traditional contact lenses are designed to sit directly on the cornea, the clear front surface of the eye. They are available in several forms, including:

Soft contact lenses
Daily disposable lenses
Bi-weekly or monthly replacement lenses
Rigid Gas Permeable (RGP) lenses
Multifocal lenses
Toric lenses for astigmatism

These lenses are widely used to correct common vision problems such as nearsightedness, farsightedness, astigmatism, and presbyopia.

What Are Scleral Lenses?

Scleral lenses ...
... are large-diameter gas-permeable contact lenses that vault over the cornea and rest on the sclera, the white part of the eye. Unlike traditional lenses, scleral lenses create a fluid-filled reservoir between the lens and the cornea.

This unique design provides both vision correction and continuous hydration for the eye's surface, making them particularly beneficial for patients with irregular corneas or severe dry eye syndrome.

Key Differences Between Scleral Lenses and Traditional Contact Lenses
1. Lens Size

One of the most noticeable differences is size.

Traditional Contact Lenses

Smaller diameter
Sit directly on the cornea
Cover only part of the eye's surface

Scleral Lenses

Larger diameter
Cover the entire cornea
Rest on the sclera rather than the cornea

The larger size of scleral lenses contributes to improved comfort and stability for many patients.

2. Comfort Level

Comfort is a major factor when choosing contact lenses.

Traditional lenses can sometimes cause irritation, especially for individuals with dry eyes or sensitive corneas. Since they move with each blink and sit directly on the cornea, discomfort may develop throughout the day.

Scleral lenses, on the other hand, do not touch the cornea. The fluid layer beneath the lens provides constant moisture and cushioning, often resulting in superior comfort, particularly for patients with eye surface disorders.

3. Vision Quality

For individuals with standard vision prescriptions, traditional contact lenses typically provide excellent visual correction.

However, patients with irregular corneas may experience blurred or distorted vision even with standard lenses.

Scleral lenses create a smooth optical surface over the eye, often delivering sharper and more stable vision for people with:

Keratoconus
Corneal scarring
Post-LASIK complications
Corneal transplants
Severe astigmatism
4. Dry Eye Relief

Traditional contact lenses may worsen symptoms of dry eye by absorbing moisture from the tear film.

Scleral lenses are often recommended as a treatment option for dry eye because they maintain a reservoir of sterile saline solution between the lens and the cornea.

Patients suffering from:

Chronic dry eye syndrome
Sjögren's syndrome
Ocular surface disease
Exposure keratopathy

often experience significant relief with scleral lenses.

5. Stability on the Eye

Traditional contact lenses can shift during blinking or physical activity.

Scleral lenses provide enhanced stability because they rest on the less sensitive sclera rather than the cornea. This stability helps maintain consistent vision throughout the day.

6. Customization

Most traditional soft contact lenses are mass-produced in standard sizes and prescriptions.

Scleral lenses are highly customized based on detailed measurements of the eye. Advanced imaging technology allows eye care professionals to design lenses that precisely fit each patient's unique eye shape.

This personalized fit contributes to better comfort and visual performance.

7. Application and Removal

Traditional soft lenses are generally easier for beginners to insert and remove.

Scleral lenses require a slightly different process:

The lens must be filled with sterile saline before insertion.
Proper handling techniques are necessary.
Patients may need additional training during the fitting process.

While the learning curve is slightly longer, most patients become comfortable with the process after a short adjustment period.

8. Cost Considerations

Traditional contact lenses are usually less expensive initially.

Scleral lenses often involve:

Specialized fitting appointments
Custom manufacturing
Advanced diagnostic imaging

Although the upfront cost may be higher, many patients find the improved comfort, vision quality, and eye health benefits well worth the investment.

Who Should Consider Scleral Lenses?

Scleral lenses may be an excellent option if you have:

Keratoconus
Severe dry eye disease
Corneal irregularities
Corneal scarring
Post-surgical corneal complications
Difficulty wearing traditional contact lenses
Poor vision with standard contacts

An eye care professional can determine whether scleral lenses are appropriate for your specific condition.

Who Is a Good Candidate for Traditional Contact Lenses?

Traditional contact lenses remain a great choice for many people who:

Have healthy eyes
Need correction for common refractive errors
Prefer a lower-cost option
Want daily disposable convenience
Have no significant corneal abnormalities

For these individuals, traditional soft lenses often provide excellent comfort and vision correction.

Final Thoughts

Both scleral lenses and traditional contact lenses offer effective vision correction, but they serve different needs. Traditional contact lenses are ideal for most people with standard prescriptions, while scleral lenses provide life-changing benefits for individuals with complex eye conditions, irregular corneas, and severe dry eye.