Who Decides Your Overthinking, Anyway?

By Author: Imperfect
Total Articles: 1115
Comment this article

Overthinking is one of the most misunderstood psychological patterns. Often, it isn’t you who first decides that you’re overthinking—it’s the people around you who say, “You’re thinking too much.” This external feedback can feel invalidating, confusing, or even shaming. But the real question is not who labels it—it’s how you can tell when thinking crosses into overthinking, and what truly deserves your mental energy.

As Dostoyevsky once said, “To think too much is a disease.”

While dramatic, it captures a familiar truth: overthinking is less about intelligence and more about mental loops that keep us stuck.

Thinking vs Overthinking: What’s the Difference?
Thinking Has Movement- Healthy thinking leads to clarity, decisions, or action. Example: Reflecting on a conversation and deciding to address something directly.

Overthinking Has Loops- Overthinking repeats the same thought without resolution. Example: Replaying a harmless joke you made days ago and feeling ashamed, even though no one else remembers. A simple rule: If it won’t matter in a week, give it five minutes. ...
... Most thoughts lose power when you don’t attach meaning to them

Why Others Say You’re Overthinking Before You Do?
External Perspective vs Internal Fear- Others notice repetition, hesitation, and avoidance. You experience it as being “careful” or “self-aware.” Example: You rehearse conversations endlessly; others see indecision. Psychologically, overthinking often shows up as pre-emptive embarrassment—trying to outsmart mistakes before they happen, which ironically stops action altogether.

Overthinking Is Often Procrastination in Disguise
Analysis Replacing Action- The mind convinces you that more thinking equals better outcomes. Example: Imagining worst-case reactions instead of sending the email. But clarity rarely comes from sitting with fear. Action breaks mental loops. Doing something—even imperfectly—grounds the mind in reality.

When Self-Awareness Turns Into Self-Attack (The Therapy Trap)

People who are reflective and perfectionistic often ask, “What am I doing wrong?” Example: Assuming failed relationships mean you are emotionally flawed. While insight can be helpful, too much responsibility becomes self-blame. Therapy isn’t only about fixing yourself—it’s also about learning to do less, not try harder.

The Need for Answers Can Keep You Stuck- Uncertainty Feels Dangerous

Some minds demand closure to feel safe. Example: Needing to know exactly why someone rejected you before moving on. Mental health isn’t about having all the answers—it’s about tolerating not having them. Growth happens when you can choose without certainty.

Perfectionism and Core Beliefs- The Burden of Proof Problem

Perfectionistic minds believe negative core beliefs easily and dismiss positive evidence.

Example: One rejection outweighs years of connection. At some point, the question shifts from “Why did this happen?” to “Can I live well without knowing?”

Doing Less Can Be Healing

Overthinking isn’t a character flaw—it’s an attempt to feel safe, worthy, or prepared. But life doesn’t reward endless analysis; it rewards engagement. What if you didn’t need one more answer—just one small step forward?

How