123ArticleOnline Logo
Welcome to 123ArticleOnline.com!
ALL >> Legal >> View Article

Doj Ruling On Disabled Rights In Cruise Ships

Profile Picture
By Author: Lala C. Ballatan
Total Articles: 4
Comment this article
Facebook ShareTwitter ShareGoogle+ ShareTwitter Share

It is interesting to note that many disabled persons, instead of slinking away and being embarrassed by their conditions, are asserting their rights. They already educate themselves with the basics of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) of 1990, a law which protects them against discrimination and rules that establishments and such give proper accommodations for them.

Adopted to remove the barriers that prevented the society from benefiting from the participation and contributions of individuals with disabilities, the ADA took effect in July 26, 1990. Its Title I prohibits private employers, state and local governments, employment agencies and labor unions from discriminating against qualified individuals with disabilities - whether in job application, procedures, hiring, firing, advancement, compensation, job training and other terms, conditions and privileges of employment. It also has the qualifications of a person with disability. Four other titles of ADA includes other aspects where the issue of disability is very much considered: public services and public transportation, public accommodations, telecommunications ...
... and miscellaneous.

Many states have also adopted and enforce versions of the federal ADA. Now, on the Supreme Court rulings posted by Peggy McGuiness at Opinio Juris, referred to by Walter Olson on March 2, 2005 at the site, http://www.overlawyered.com/archives/cat_disabled_rights.html several important and interesting issues about the ADA were raised.

An argument ensued at the Supreme Court when the Department of Justice (DOJ) sided with a group of disabled cruise passengers who sued Norwegian Cruise Lines (NCL) for failing to provide the kinds of accommodations required on public transportation under the Americans with Disabilities Act. The defendant, NCL argues that they should be exempt from ADA regulation in the same way that they are exempt from federal labor laws because their ships fly under the Bahamian flag. The DOJ and the plaintiffs argue that the ADA can be applied to foreign flagged vessels operating in US waters precisely because they come in and out of US jurisdiction and operate as a public accommodation.

Now, this is really quite an ruling since it essentially goes beyond the international law, which maintain that ships are generally only subject to the jurisdiction of the state under whose flag they sail. Infact, cruiselines choose to register under foreign flags precisely to avoid certain regulatory restrictions and costs (i.e., taxation, labor and employment laws).

The DOJ ruling favoring the disabled has become a broad application of the ADA to foreign-flagged vessels. This might even be conceivably applied not only to cruise ships, but also to every merchant marine vessel that ever enters US waters. But cruiselines are not interested in complying with the nation's stringent ADA since compliance in those circumstances would be extraordinarily expensive and a burden on trade.

I think there's nothing wrong with the ruling, though. It's just that, public services, transportation and all other busness establishments must not just think about the expenses that go with compliance on several laws. They must simply learn to respect the rights of disabled citizens.

About the Author For additional Information about the articles you may visit http://www.wheelchairspower.com

Total Views: 237Word Count: 503See All articles From Author

Add Comment

Legal Articles

1. A Complete Guide To Online Food License Registration In Pune
Author: Startupporta Business Services

2. Why Smart Sellers Choose Virtual Offices: Thegstco’s Gst-ready Solution For E-commerce Growth
Author: shrutika

3. How Human Error Causes Most Train Accidents
Author: Law Offices of Eslamboly Hakim

4. A Guide To Divorce Proceedings In Singapore
Author: Singapore Sole Parent

5. What Is The Role Of Lawyers In Abu Dhabi’s Real Estate Market?
Author: Dr. Hassan Elhais

6. Self-sponsorship Visa Uk: Establishing Your Family Business In The Uk
Author: The SmartMove2UK

7. Trusted Guidance From Family Lawyers In Saskatoon
Author: John Smith

8. The Art Of Cross Examination In Commercial Arbitration
Author: Anna Paquin

9. Step-by-step Guide To Securing 12a Registration For Ngos And Trusts In India
Author: Ishita Ramani

10. Top Packers And Movers In Lahore: Your Ultimate Moving Solution
Author: paker

11. How Outsourcing Medical Record Retrieval Services Improves Efficiency
Author: 1Point1 Solutions

12. Your British Passport: Your Key To The World!
Author: Conroy Baker

13. Motorcycle Lawyer In Lubbock: Your Advocate After A Crash
Author: Mark Taylor

14. Motorcycle Lawyer In Waco: Your Advocate On The Open Road
Author: Mark Taylor

15. Motorcycle Injury Attorneys In Austin: Your Guide To Legal Support After An Accident
Author: Mark Taylor

Login To Account
Login Email:
Password:
Forgot Password?
New User?
Sign Up Newsletter
Email Address: