Oxbow Timothy Vs Orchard Grass Hay: Which Is Better For Your Small Pets?

By Author: VetSupply
Total Articles: 316
Comment this article

If you're a proud pet parent of a rabbit, guinea pig, or chinchilla, you already know that hay is life. Literally. It’s the foundation of their diet and crucial to their health and happiness. But with so many options out there—Timothy, Oxbow Timothy/Orchard, Alfalfa—choosing the right one can feel like solving a puzzle.

Two of the most loved options? Oxbow’s Timothy Hay and Orchard Grass Hay. Let’s break down the difference between them, so you can pick the best for your furball.

Understanding Hay's Role in Small Pet Diets
Hay isn’t just filler—it’s the backbone of a small herbivore’s diet. It keeps things moving in their digestive tract (fiber is key!) and helps prevent nasty issues like GI stasis.

But that’s not all. Because their teeth never stop growing, chewing on coarse hay helps wear teeth down naturally—like nature intended. Plus, foraging and nibbling on hay all day mimics their behavior in the wild.

What Is Oxbow Timothy Hay?
Oxbow’s Western Timothy Hay is considered ...
... the gold standard for adult small animals.

Fiber-rich: Ideal for supporting digestive health.

Coarse and crunchy: Encourages chewing and tooth wear.

Aromatic: Earthy and fresh, it appeals to most small pets.

This hay is harvested at the ideal stage for maximum nutrition and packed with care to preserve freshness.

What Is Oxbow Orchard Grass Hay?
Think of Orchard Grass as Timothy Hay’s sweeter, softer cousin.

Lower in fiber but still healthy: Great for variety.

Soft texture: Ideal for younger, senior, or picky pets.

Naturally sweet smell: Pets love the aroma—it can make hesitant eaters chow down happily.

It’s also less dusty, which is a win for allergy-prone households.

Comparing Timothy and Orchard Grass Hay
Fiber and Protein Levels
Timothy Hay: Higher in fiber, slightly lower in protein—ideal for adult rabbits and guinea pigs.

Orchard Grass: Slightly lower fiber but still acceptable for daily feeding.

Texture and Toughness
Timothy is more coarse and stemmy—great for dental wear.

Orchard Grass is leafy and soft—easy on the mouth.

Flavor and Palatability
Timothy has a more neutral, earthy taste.

Orchard Grass is naturally sweet, and often more appealing to picky eaters.

Allergen Potential (for Pets and Humans)
Orchard Grass tends to be less dusty, so it’s great if you or your pet has hay allergies.

Which Hay is Best for Rabbits?
For adult rabbits, Timothy Hay is the top choice thanks to its ideal fiber content and tough texture that promotes dental health.

However, if your rabbit turns up their nose at Timothy, Orchard Grass is a great substitute—or can be mixed in for variety.

Which Hay is Best for Guinea Pigs?
Guinea pigs can be very opinionated eaters. Timothy is a great everyday hay for their diet, but mixing in Orchard Grass can keep them interested. Remember, they need unlimited hay daily—boredom is not an option.

What About Chinchillas?
Chinchillas require very high-fiber diets to maintain digestive health. Oxbow Timothy is perfect for them. But if you want to keep things exciting, Orchard Grass can be added occasionally—just make sure they’re still getting enough roughage.

Can You Mix Timothy and Orchard Grass Hay?
Absolutely, yes! Many pet parents find that blending the two:

Keeps pets interested

Encourages picky eaters

Offers a mix of textures and flavors

Think of it like a hay salad—tasty, varied, and full of fiber.

Dental Benefits of Both Hays
Timothy Hay wins for toughness, which really helps grind down teeth.
But don’t underestimate Orchard Grass—its soft but fibrous texture still offers plenty of chewing resistance, especially when mixed with Timothy.

Allergy Considerations
If hay makes you sneeze every time you clean the cage, Orchard Grass might be your best bet. It’s typically softer and produces less dust, making it more comfortable for both pets and humans.

Oxbow also offers low-dust varieties—great for anyone sensitive to airborne particles.

How Oxbow Ensures Quality
Oxbow isn’t just a name—it’s a promise of consistency.

Hay is harvested at peak nutrition.

Hand-sorted to remove debris.

Packaged with care to seal in freshness.

No wonder vets recommend it worldwide.

Storage Tips for Maximum Freshness
Hay is like produce—it goes bad if not stored right.

Store in a cool, dry area away from sunlight.

Use breathable containers like fabric bags or cardboard boxes (never airtight plastic).

Keep it off the floor to prevent moisture buildup.

Feeding Guidelines
Your pet should have unlimited access to fresh hay. Here’s a general rule of thumb:

Rabbits & guinea pigs: Hay should make up 80–90% of their diet.

Chinchillas: Always have fresh hay available—especially Timothy.

Availability and Where to Buy
You can find Oxbow Timothy and Orchard Grass Hay:

Online (Amazon, Chewy, PetCircle)

In local pet shops

Through vet clinics

Want to save money? Look for bulk packages or auto-ship subscriptions.

Conclusion
So—Oxbow Timothy or Orchard Grass?

If you’re after high fiber, dental support, and balanced nutrition—go with Timothy.
If your pet is picky, has soft teeth, or you suffer from hay dust allergies—Orchard Grass might be your winner.

But honestly? You don’t have to choose. Mixing both gives your pet the best of both worlds—a delicious and healthy hay buffet!

FAQs
Q1: Can I switch hay brands suddenly?
It’s best to mix the new hay in gradually to avoid digestive upset and resistance.

Q2: Is Orchard Grass safe for baby rabbits?
Yes! While young bunnies may benefit from alfalfa hay early on, Orchard Grass is a gentle alternative as they transition to adult hays.

Q3: How do I know if hay is stale?
If it smells musty, is yellow/brown instead of green, or feels damp—it's time to toss it.

Q4: Can I feed hay on the floor of the cage?
Yes, but make sure it's clean and dry. Using a hay rack or pile on bedding helps keep it fresh.

Q5: Do pets get bored of the same hay?
Absolutely! That’s why mixing Timothy and Orchard Grass is such a great idea—it keeps their interest and appetite up.