ALL >> General >> View Article
Sonia Rodriguez – Defeating Defense Medical Experts
Michael calls this spade a spade right from the get-go, in that the title of “defense medical experts” is a sham. Many times, he says, they are called “independent experts” when they are neither independent nor an expert, not to mention the fact that they are hand-picked by defense lawyers who pay them for their testimony. Michael believes it is a huge fraud being perpetrated on our clients, on the jury, and on the court system. He says, typically “we know what their report is going to say once we hear their name,” further exemplifying this flaw in the system.
So, Michael asks, “what do we do to expose this and show the jurors the truth?” Sonia believes it is critical we expose the relationships experts have with the lawyers who hired them, how often they’ve been used by that firm or the defense industry, as well as how much money they make from that business. She also uncovers what percentage of their business is spent on reviewing files for defense lawyers vs. practicing medicine, in some cases. All of which can go a long way in revealing these witnesses for what they really are, which is “paid opinion witnesses.” Michael also explains how he doesn’t like to even use the word “expert,” which gives them the mantle of that title. He goes on to discuss the harsh reality and his distain for medical professionals who misuse their degrees to go against the very oath they have taken to “do no harm,” while we represent legitimately injured clients, and they do it for money! They both agree how uncovering the financial ties and bias of these witnesses also says a lot about them because they could likely be making much more money by seeing patients, but instead are reviewing cases for a defense lawyer. Michael also talks through a real example of what he’s run into on how these medical witnesses come to find themselves making money in this way and how their path toward testifying can ironically parallel his client’s paths.
Michael and Sonia share a plethora of examples regarding their tactics on utilizing depositions, both past and present, to build their cases, ranging from networking with other attorneys and medical professionals to leveraging amazon.com in the middle of a deposition. Sonia explains how you cannot go into a deposition with a broad brush, but rather be laser-focused and able to drill down on even a single word, in some cases, to make your entire case. And to sum things up, Michael talks through the very polarizing two ends of the spectrum his preparations take him with defense medical experts, where they are likely to either be way “off the deep end” and obviously working as a paid witness, or he will focus his energies on essentially turning them to help his case. The strategies they both describe are pure methodical genius.
The conversation shifts to talk specifically about the tone and demeanor both Michael and Sonia use when deposing paid medical witnesses. They both agree the tone and demeaner you use in a paid medical witness deposition is extremely important, as it will likely be replayed for the jury at some point and jurors will also be watching to see how you handle yourself in this situation, the same way they do in the courtroom. We, as plaintiff attorneys, also need to be cognizant of how we are approaching the deposition so it leads the jury to come to their own conclusions regarding the credibility of the paid medical witness and their testimony. It also becomes reflective for the jury to feel the danger themselves of allowing these paid medical witnesses to get away with using their titles as a form of “expertness” in exchange for being paid by the defense. In other words, if we just “rip into them” it will likely backfire on us and not work at all in our favor. Not to mention, Sonia adds, that today’s juries are tired of the theatrics and enthusiastic approach of some lawyers, where the days of yelling and pounding your fist on the table are now long gone.
All in all, this Table Talk with Michael and Sonia was thorough and filled with an enormous number of real examples from their experiences over the years. As a trial lawyer, you will likely run into paid medical witnesses in trials often, and this table talk could be the one thing that prepares you most for success.
If you want to listen this podcast click on the given link:
Author: Sonia Rodriguez and Michael Cowen
In this popular trial lawyer podcast, Michael Cowen and his guests explore critical topics distinctive to the legal profession - specifically focusing on developing extremely efficient law practices, securing a competitive edge in the industry, and wildly excelling in the courtroom.
General Articles1. Event Management Software Market Report (2018-2026)
Author: Unknown Member
2. The Many Uses Of The Sola Wood
Author: Abby Clare
3. Digestive Health Products Market In-depth Analysis, Size, Share, Cagr Status, Research Report
Author: Nikhil khadilkar
4. Why Web Research Is Important For Business Organizations?
Author: Irene Emily
5. The Benefits Of Screen Enclosure During The Holidays In Naples, Fl
Author: Aluminum Master LLC
6. How To Deal With Swollen Feet
Author: Derry Hall
7. Ist Das Hochzeitskleid Für Viele Der Wichtigsten Modeartikel
8. Buying Inflatable Tents Is Really Useful
Author: Mark Bachman
9. Raaga Imperio | Venues | Banquet Hall | Tathawade | Pune | Baithebaithe
Author: ambre sanjay
10. Manage The Comfortable Body With The Best Therapy
11. Sony A7r Iv Camera: Your Way To Picture Perfection
Author: Camera Warehouse
12. Bird Repellent Devices Work Superb & Are Effective
13. How To Use Nd Filter For Perfect Landscape Photography – A Complete Guide
Author: Camera Warehouse
14. Wedding+photography=beautiful Memories
Author: Shailesh Tiwadi
15. Production Of The Compound Fertilizer