ALL >> Business >> View Article
Towards A Sociolinguistics Of Communities

While these criticisms demonstrate the limitations of the Three Circles model, it must also be recognized that the major assumptions of the model correlation between socio-political history and local status of English, the centrality of the nation-state, and the privileged status attributed to (traditional) native speakers are 'real', in the sense that they point to prevalent language ideologies that influentially shape and constrain local uses of English across many contexts around the world. This is where we locate the utility of Kachru's model despite its problems, and this is what motivates us to suggest a refraining of the model as Five Fingers Shoes one that represents the system of ideological forces that delimit local creativity and utility of English in the world.
In fact, a language-ideological turn is important for understanding the status of English in the world, as the pursuit of 'descriptive precision' (in terms of coming up with more specific labels and categories) is of limited value in the absence of any understanding of how those categories emerge and function ...
... via the mediation of language ideologies.2 For instance, while complaints that the model fails to recognize more than just national varieties are well founded, the answer to this patently does not lie in trying to identify more and more varieties of English. To appreciate this, we need to only observe that the label 'Indian English' is a convenient cover term for a range of regional and social varieties that sometimes go by names like 'Marathi English', 'Hindustani English', 'Boxwallah English', 'Babu English', and 'Kitchen English' (Schneider 2007: 168). And, clearly, even any attention to a regional variety such as 'Marathi English' is equally open to the objection that this label, too, overlooks the variation in regional linguistic practices, and so on.
Such moves are problematic because they assume that both languages and speakers of those languages are 'amenable to counting' where '[t]o abstract languages, to count them as discrete objects, and to count the speakers of Five Fingers KSO such languages, is to reproduce a very particular enumerative strategy, one that reduces "significant sociolinguistic concerns to the level of arithmetic", and overlooks "the problematic history of the construction of such languages. We therefore need to constantly remind ourselves that labels for varieties are a result of simplification of complex sociolinguistic situations and thus represent convenient generalizations that are grounded upon particular social positions (Irvine and Gal 2000). In fact, understandings of how particular grammatical constructions belong to specific varieties are usually the historical products of broader socio-political acts of labeling: particular constructional repertoires become categorized as belonging to variety A, while others are classified as belonging to variety B. These meta-discursive regimes or representations about language reflect socially invented understandings of language, in particular, conceptualizations of varieties as 'separate and enumerable categories'.
Add Comment
Business Articles
1. Lucintel Forecasts The Global Wall-mounted Ac Ev Charger Market To Grow With A Cagr Of 22.4% From 2025 To 2031Author: Lucintel LLC
2. Technology Landscape, Trends And Opportunities In Global 3d Printing Photopolymer Market
Author: Lucintel LLC
3. Lucintel Forecasts The Global Smart Home Market To Reach $372 Billion By 2030
Author: Lucintel LLC
4. Second Marriage Matrimonial – Verified Matches & Free Registration
Author: Truelymarry
5. Core: Leading The Way In Managed It Services For Businesses Across London
Author: IT Management
6. The Role And Function Of A Collection Agency
Author: Bennett Carter
7. Understanding Debt Collection Agencies: What They Do And How They Affect Consumers
Author: Bennett Carter
8. How To Use An Smm Panel Effectively For Fast Social Media Growth
Author: Smm Panel
9. Essential Tips For Beginners And The Power Of Professional Editing
Author: Sam
10. How To Improve Field Staff Efficiency With Geolocation Tools
Author: TrackHr App
11. Building An Effective Energy Management System
Author: Jane
12. Internal Auditor Training: The Key To Effective Risk Management And Compliance
Author: Sqccertification
13. Why Accurate Accounting In Property Management Is The Key To Higher Roi
Author: Harsh Vardhan
14. Kaal Sarp Puja In Trimbakeshwar – Benefits, Process & Trusted Pandit Contact
Author: Pandit Milind Guruji
15. Data Entry Vs. Data Processing: What’s The Difference And Why It Matters
Author: Allianze BPO