123ArticleOnline Logo
Welcome to 123ArticleOnline.com!

ALL >> Business >> View Article

Why Are Aap And Congress Supporters Opposing A Tax Reform Like The Gst? Are They Anti-nationals?

By Author: Mohit Yadev
Total Articles: 102

GST will have the same negative impact as “Demonetization” and as fancy as it seems to have a single tax structure, it will slow down the Indian economy and be an unsuccessful shot in the dark.
ANTI-PROFITEERING CLAUSE
One of the most important factors that everyone seems to miss is that the Centre and the States have agreed on an anti-profiteering clause in the GST.
The government has basically created a new authority which will decide whether businesses have reduced their prices enough when there is a reduction in the GST rate of the concerned good or service and, has the power of canceling registration if found guilty of profiteering and not passing on the tax benefit to consumers.
Discover More GST Billing Software.
The pestering and the intimidation of the tax police to examine a company’s pricing structure to see whether a tax cut has been passed on or not is just absurd and time-consuming, to say the least. The whole concept of free market mechanism seems to go on a holiday and the pricing structure will be controlled by the tax watchmen resulting in tremendous workload for the corporates.
The current mechanism is too broad-based and difficult to implement. Is it possible to act against an eatery in Delhi that does not pass on the gains of the tax cut to consumers?
Such a clause is only useful when proper time is given to businesses to understand the nitty gritties of GST.
It has been hastily implemented in India.
Malaysia had implemented an anti-profiteering just ahead of its GST roll out and the move was a disastrous one which actually slowed down the whole business sector and it was finally been removed. We must take a leaf out of Malaysia’s GST book.
Killing the competitiveness of the Indian market
The Indian states compete with each other to attract private investment by offering lower taxes in comparison to others. That subtly explains why Gujarat got the Tata Nano deal ultimately because it commanded lower taxes in comparison to other states.
With a single tax structure all over India, it would kill competition and it would make no difference whether to establish a manufacturing unit in Bengal or Karnataka. Historically and logically, it is always in the interests of the consumer and a corporate if there is healthy competition.
The Death Of The Federal Structure
Everyone agrees to the simple fact that GST is fundamentally anti-federal which is the sole reason why states have been resisting it. They won’t be able to raise or lower taxes as they see fit economically or politically and will always need to go to the GST Council to bring about changes. The whole voting structure to bring about change in tax rate is flawed and heavily in favor of the Union Government. Also, once in, states will not be able to opt out of GST.
All in all, GST is poised to be the next big failure in the slew of disappointing steps taken by the government.

Total Views: 17Word Count: 488See All articles From Author

Business Articles

1. A Simplified Way Of Registering Trademark In China
Author: Vincent Qin

2. Starter Culture Market Size, Share, Trends And Growth Analysis, Industry Forecast To 2025 By Credenc
Author: Chris Smith

3. The Various Types Of Water Pumps Available
Author: Gbenga Kukler

4. Five Ideas For Publishers To Help Their Advertisers
Author: MichaelDavidWilson

5. Webrtc Market Size, Share, Trends And Growth Analysis, Industry Forecast To 2025 By Credence Researc
Author: Chris Smith

6. Medicine Degree From The University
Author: slimlifesolutions

7. Travel Agency In Africa – It’s Time To Receive Customized And Budget Friendly African Holiday Packag
Author: Sandy Russell

8. Avail Customs Broker Us Border Services For Smooth And Speedy Transit Of Your Goods At The Us Ports
Author: adkenkaylyn

9. Food Containers Market Size, Share, Trends And Growth Analysis, Industry Forecast To 2025 By Credenc
Author: Chris Smith

10. Denied Party Screening – The Toughest Measures You Can Take
Author: Fred Danny

11. Heart Valve Devices Market Size, Share, Trends And Growth Analysis, Industry Forecast To 2025 By Cre
Author: Chris Smith

12. Grants Pass Eye Lash Extensions
Author: loftybeautylounge

13. Top 5 Cleaning And Maintenance Tips For Commercial Kitchen Equipments
Author: Meenakshi Jain

14. Key To Purchasing Some Of The Best Seneca Sc Homes For Sale By The Lake
Author: Joseph Atkins

15. Chia Seeds Market Trends And Growth Analysis, Industry Forecast To 2025 By Credence Research
Author: Chris Smith

Login To Account
Login Email:
Password:
Forgot Password?
New User?
Sign Up Newsletter
Email Address: